Thinking about building a new deck or replacing an old one? Great! A deck is more than just a structure—it’s where you enjoy summer BBQs, relax with a morning coffee, and create lasting memories with family and friends. But before you get started, you have one big decision to make: composite or wood decking.
Both these popular options have their pros and cons, and if you’re in Southwestern Ontario, you’ve probably heard plenty of opinions on both. Wood has that classic, natural charm, while composite decking is praised for its durability and low maintenance. But is composite decking really worth the hype? Or is traditional wood still the way to go?
As a decking contractor, I’m here to break it all down for you. Let’s dive in and help you decide which decking material best suits your home, budget, and lifestyle.
What is Composite Decking?
Composite decking is made from a mix of recycled plastic and wood fibers, making it an eco-friendly and long-lasting alternative to traditional wood. It’s available in a variety of colors and designs, often mimicking the look of real wood. The plastic in composite decking makes it highly resistant to moisture, rot, and insects, so it requires very little upkeep.
There are two main types of composite decking:
- Capped Composite Decking – Comes with a protective outer layer that shields it from moisture, UV rays, stains, and fading. It’s more durable and lasts longer.
- Uncapped Composite Decking – Lacks the protective coating, making it more vulnerable to the elements over time.
If you want a long-lasting, low-maintenance deck, capped composite is the way to go.
What is Wood Decking?
Wood decking is exactly what it sounds like—real, natural wood. Some of the most common choices include cedar, redwood, and exotic hardwoods like Ipe. There’s also pressure-treated wood, which is chemically treated to resist insects and rot.
Wood is a more affordable option upfront, but it requires regular maintenance (sealing, staining, and sanding) to keep it looking good and structurally sound. If you love the natural beauty of wood and don’t mind a little upkeep, it could be a great choice.
Composite vs. Wood Decking: Key Differences
Choosing between wood and composite decking comes down to several factors. Let’s compare them side by side so you can make an informed decision.
1. Maintenance & Care
- Wood Decking: Needs regular sanding, staining, and sealing to prevent moisture damage, warping, and insect infestations.
- Composite Decking: No need for sanding, sealing, or staining. Just a simple sweep or wash keeps it looking fresh.
If you want a low-maintenance deck, go with composite. If you don’t mind the upkeep and love the look of real wood, then wood decking is for you.
2. Upfront Cost
- Wood Decking: Generally cheaper upfront, with pressure-treated wood being the most budget-friendly option.
- Composite Decking: Higher initial cost but offers better value in the long run due to lower maintenance expenses.
If you’re on a tight budget, wood decking is the better initial investment. If you’re thinking long-term, composite decking can save you money over time.
3. Long-Term Value
- Wood Decking: While it’s cheaper upfront, ongoing maintenance costs (sealers, stains, repairs) add up.
- Composite Decking: More expensive at first, but since it requires little to no maintenance, you’ll save money over the years.
If you want better lifetime value, composite decking wins hands down.
4. Moisture Resistance
- Wood Decking: Absorbs water, which can lead to swelling, warping, and rot if not properly sealed.
- Composite Decking: Highly moisture-resistant due to its plastic content, making it ideal for wet climates.
If your deck will be exposed to a lot of moisture, composite decking is the better choice.
5. Appearance
- Wood Decking: Offers a natural, traditional look with unique grain patterns.
- Composite Decking: Designed to look like wood but retains color and shape longer with less maintenance.
If you want an authentic wood look, real wood is unbeatable. If you want something that keeps its appearance with minimal effort, composite decking is the way to go.
6. Environmental Impact
- Wood Decking: More demand for wood can contribute to deforestation. Regular maintenance also involves chemicals that aren’t great for the environment.
- Composite Decking: Made from recycled plastic and wood fibers, reducing waste and deforestation.
If sustainability is important to you, composite decking is the eco-friendlier option.
7. Insect Resistance
- Wood Decking: Some types (like cedar and redwood) have natural insect resistance, but they’re still vulnerable over time.
- Composite Decking: Resists insect damage thanks to its plastic content.
If you want a deck that won’t attract pests, composite decking is the better choice.
8. Slip Resistance
- Wood Decking: Can be slippery when wet but can be treated to improve grip.
- Composite Decking: Newer designs come with textured surfaces for better slip resistance.
For better slip resistance, composite decking has the edge.
9. Splintering
- Wood Decking: Over time, wood can splinter, especially if not maintained.
- Composite Decking: No splinters, making it safer for bare feet and pets.
If you want a splinter-free deck, go with composite.
10. Heat Resistance
- Wood Decking: Stays cooler in the sun compared to traditional composite decking.
- Composite Decking: This can retain heat, but newer models are designed with heat-resistant technology to stay cooler.
If your deck will be in direct sunlight, look for heat-resistant composite or opt for wood.
Final Thoughts
So, which one should you choose? Well, that depends on your priorities:
Go with wood decking if you love the natural look, don’t mind regular maintenance, and want a lower upfront cost.
Choose composite decking if you prefer a long-lasting, low-maintenance deck with better durability and value over time.
Either way, your deck should be an investment that enhances your outdoor space and fits your lifestyle. If you’re still unsure which option is best for you, we’re happy to help! Feel free to reach out to the best deck builders in Southwestern Ontario—The Deck Master. We’d love to bring your dream deck to life!
0 Comments